13 Old-Fashioned Cookie Recipes You Need to Know — Eat This Not That

13 Old-Fashioned Cookie Recipes You Need to Know — Eat This Not That

Can you imagine it? You step into your grandmother’s kitchen, and the wafting smell of (insert whatever cookie you love) hits your nose. You melt with satisfaction and rush to the table, where a warm batch of (insert that cookie you love again) is waiting for you to devour with a glass of milk. If you’re the type who loves to take a trip down memory lane and want to recreate that delectable moment in grandma’s kitchen, then you’ll need this list of old-fashioned cookie recipes.

From straight-up classic cookies to those with fun twists, these cookies will certainly make your stone-cold heart melt with every delicious, ooey-gooey bite.

Plus, don’t miss 15 Cozy Old-Fashioned Casserole Recipes Perfect For Fall.

Kiersten Hickman/Eat This, Not That!

You can never go wrong with a classic snickerdoodle, and these work for every kind of occasion—summer cookout? Holiday cookie swap? Have you enjoyed a steaming cup of tea on a crisp fall weekend? Indeed, a versatile cookie for any time of the year.

Get our recipe for Snickerdoodle Cookies.

filling jelly into thumbprint cookie
Kiersten Hickman/Eat This, Not That!

No matter the filling—whether it’s jam or marmalade or caramel or chocolate frosting—a thumbprint cookie is quintessential nostalgia. Use the base of this recipe to get started, then feel free to upgrade our recipe to make the version that your mom or grandma loved to bake!

Get our recipe for Jelly Thumbprints.

finished gingerbread cookies on a marble counter
Kiersten Hickman/Eat This, Not That!

How could we make a list of old-fashioned cookie recipes and not include the classic gingerbread? This recipe will have you craving holiday music, cozy scarves, and steaming mugs of hot cocoa with every single bite.

Get our recipe for Gingerbread cookies.

Courtesy of The Cozy Cook

Nothing like dipping a shortbread cookie in an afternoon cup of tea. Make a batch of these shortbread cookies and have them on hand when you’re itching for a tea break in the middle of the day.

Get the recipe from The Cozy Cook.

Icebox cookies
Courtesy of Sally’s Baking Addiction

These are the kind of cookies to always have in your back pocket. “Icebox cookies” essentially start as cookie dough formed into a log and then refrigerated to make them firm. Then you slice up the cookies based on how many you want (maybe it’s just one or two, it’s perhaps the whole batch) and bake!

Get the recipe from Sally’s Baking Addiction.

RELATED: This Surprising Ingredient Makes Cookies Healthier, New Study Finds

Gingersnap cookies
Courtesy of Chelsea’s Messy Apron

If you’re looking for a softer and chewier cookie than the crispy gingerbread cookie, these gingersnaps are the answer to your prayers. They are rich and flavor and make for the perfect snack in the afternoon with whatever drink you enjoy—coffee, tea, wine? They’re that versatile.

Get the recipe from Chelsea’s Messy Apron.

Rum balls
Courtesy of Foxes Love Lemons

Maybe you only associate rum balls with the holidays, but why not enjoy them year-round? This old-fashioned cookie works with any coating you desire. Powdered sugar? Sprinkles? Coarse sugar? Feel free to get creative here.

Get the recipe from Foxes Love Lemons.

Almond cookies
Courtesy of Lil Luna

Maybe you weren’t always a fan of almond-flavored treats, but you can’t deny that almond cookies are classically old-fashioned. So top your cookies with a layer of homemade almond frosting and sliced almonds (or sprinkles, we won’t judge), and enjoy your trip down memory lane.

Get the recipe from Lil Luna.

RELATED: Secret Effects of Eating Almonds, Says Science

Italian sprinkle cookies
Courtesy of Cooking Classy

A trip to see your Italian grandmother probably meant a steaming pot of homemade red gravy and a batch of her sugary Italian sprinkle cookies. So next time you’re cooking up an Italian feast (especially one of these 53+ Healthy Italian Recipes), don’t forget to finish the meal with a few. With a cup of espresso, of course.

Get the recipe from Cooking Classy.

Pinwheel cookies
Courtesy of Diethood

Whether the pinwheel cookies of your youth included two different colored doughs or were filled to the brim with sugary nuts and treats, both will satisfy that craving for sugar—and a little nostalgic taste of home.

Get the recipe from Diethood.

Lace cookies
Courtesy of Half Baked Harvest

Ever wonder how grandma was able to make those intricate-looking lace cookies? Wonder no longer! This recipe will walk you step-by-step on how to make those thin, crispy creations—and a chocolate filling if you want to turn them into cookie sandwiches!

Get the recipe from Half Baked Harvest.

RELATED: 15 Vintage Cakes That Are Perfect for Birthdays

Courtesy of My Name Is Yeh

They look like mini croissants, but they’re cookies and can be made with different flavors. These cookies are filled with classic chocolate, but other recipes call for jam or a brown sugar spread for something a little different.

Get the recipe from My Name is Yeh.

butter cookies
Courtesy of Sally’s Baking Addiction

Whether they were homemade in the oven or came from a cookie tin, who can deny a butter cookie (or two, or five) when it’s time for a snack—or a little after-dinner treat?

We know Christmas is a few months away, but it’s never too early to start planning your holiday spread. So start perfecting your technique now with these old-fashioned cookie recipes everyone loves.

Spread the love
Similar Posts

Leave a Reply